The Dirty Little Secret About Warren Buffet’s Bet With A Hedge Fund Manager

The Dirty Little Secret About Warren Buffet’s Bet With A Hedge Fund Manager

By now, you may have heard that Warren Buffet made a bet with a hedge fund manager that just ended.  The bet was pretty simple.  Put up $1 million and pick the best investment for a 10 year period (bet started on 1/1/2008).  The winner would give the $1 million to the charity of their choice.  Warren Buffet’s pick was simple- the Vanguard S&P 500 Index Fund.  The hedge fund manager went with a blend of 5 fund-of-funds (basically a group of hedge funds). The bet didn’t start great for The Oracle of Omaha, as he explained in his annual letter:

The five funds-of-funds got off to a fast start, each beating the index fund in 2008. Then the roof fell in. In every one of the nine years that followed, the funds-of-funds as a whole trailed the index fund.

The result wasn’t even close.  The S&P returned a cumulative 125.5%, while my calculations show the hedge funds earned 36.3% over the same period.  Warren Buffet practiced what he preached in many of his shareholder letters.  To avoid high-cost funds, most investors should diversify in index funds and buy and hold for the long-term.

Now, here is the dirty little secret.  Warren Buffet could have made more money for his shareholders if he had followed his own advice. It turns out over that same 10 year period Berkshire Hathaway, the company managed by Warren Buffet, also underperformed the S&P 500!  Berkshire Hathaway generated a 7.7% annualized return during the 10 year period ending December 31st 2017, while the S&P 500 earned an 8.5% annualized return during that same period.

The point of this article is not to call out Warren Buffet.  As I wrote in a previous article about challenging Warren Buffet:

There are many lessons that can be learned from this bet.  Probably the biggest one is that if you ever have the opportunity to wager $1 million with the greatest investor of all-time, you should probably pass.

The lesson for all of us to remember continues to be how hard it is to beat the market by picking great stocks or funds.  Warren Buffet, who is widely considered the best investor of all time, couldn’t do it over the last 10 years.  If he can’t, what is the chance that you or your advisor can?

Information contained herein has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but its accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. It is not intended as the primary basis for financial planning or investment decisions and should not be construed as advice meeting the particular investment needs of any investor. This material has been prepared for information purposes only and is not a solicitation or an offer to buy any security or instrument or to participate in any trading strategy. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Recent Insights

June 22nd Market Commentary

It's no secret that the markets are experiencing a challenging year with many wondering if we're nearing a recession. So we asked seasoned members of our Investment Committee, Pat Collins, CFP®, EA, and Greg Hobson, CFP®, AIF®, to speak to those challenges and lend some valuable perspectives based on what they've experienced during their respected careers.

DeFAANGed: A Nightmare on Wall Street

Goliath. Achilles. The bear from The Revenant. Powerful, imposing, and victorious as these legendary figures became, their mighty falls remain infamous…

What is a CFP®? (and Why It’s Important to Work with one)

When searching for a financial advisor, you will likely see a lot of “alphabet soup” following prospective advisors’ names. While all these designations, licenses, and certifications have different education and experience requirements (and some may carry more weight than others), one certification rises above the rest as the standard for financial planning-focused advisors: the CFP®.