Where Has the Hedge Been in Hedge Funds

Where Has the Hedge Been in Hedge Funds

We are constantly reviewing the performance of various investment strategies.  Over the past couple of decades, the rise of hedge funds has been spectacular, and I thought it would be helpful if we dug into their performance at a much deeper level.  Here are some interesting statistics to review:

What you find is that hedge funds, when compared to other lower volatility strategies (bonds and diversified portfolios), have performed rather poorly.  During periods where the equity markets have been lackluster (for example, the last 5 years), you would have expected them to shine.  In fact, they have been one of the worst performers.  In addition, the worst year hedge funds experienced was 2008, with a loss of 21.37%.  This compares to a 5.24% gain in the Barclays Aggregate Bond Index and a 20.10% loss in 60% S&P 500 and 40% Barclays Aggregate Bond Index.  Not exactly what you want out of a “hedge” when the markets are falling.

I will not pretend to know all the reasons why the underperformance has occurred, but I know a large factor is fees.  The standard hedge fund charges 2% per year (on assets under management) with an additional fee of 20% of the profits.  So is this trailing performance a reason to abandon the idea of hedge funds in your portfolio?  Maybe or maybe not.  We believe that consideration should still be given to this asset class for a number of reasons:

1.  Fixed income cannot generate the steady 6% returns it has experienced in the past.  It is mathematically impossible given that 10-year treasury bond yields are currently running at 2%.  The idea that fixed income will generate inflation-beating returns in a low-risk asset class is no longer viable.  We believe that certain types of hedged strategies could offer a compelling alternative.

2.  As space continues to grow, there should be additional fee compression.  To think that a hedge fund manager can make billions of dollars per year without competition is naive.  At some point, other good managers will be willing to manage assets for lower fees (and still make tremendous income!)

3.  More regulated products are coming on the market.  Traditionally, hedge funds were run in large pools.  Over the past several years, traditional investment vehicles like mutual funds and exchange-traded funds offer hedge fund strategies.  This lowers the risk of rogue traders, excessive leverage, or other regulatory infractions.

What does Greenspring look for in an alternative hedged strategy?

1.  A strategy that is not reliant on a manager’s skill.  Fundamentally, we don’t believe that manager skill can last. Therefore, we’d rather choose strategies that actually work no matter who the manager is.  Strategies like market-neutral funds make very little sense to us…the idea that someone can go long all the good stocks and short all the bad ones is highly manager dependent and not one we believe can stand the test of time.  We focus on merger arbitrage and covered call writing which don’t require a manager to pick great stocks to perform well.

2.  Transparent fees and holdings- to date, we are only using funds registered under the Investment Advisors Act of 1940.  In short, there is additional regulation and requirements on them, reducing some of the leverage and oversight risk traditionally found in hedge funds.

3.  Low fee structures- we don’t believe any managers are worth paying 2% of assets and 20% of profits.  If they could guarantee outperformance in the future, that would be another matter, but we know they can’t.  There are very few parts of the investment process we can control.  Costs are one of them.  We focus on low-cost funds as we know it will have a positive impact on performance over time.

Information contained herein has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but its accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. It is not intended as the primary basis for financial planning or investment decisions and should not be construed as advice meeting the particular investment needs of any investor. This material has been prepared for information purposes only and is not a solicitation or an offer to buy any security or instrument or to participate in any trading strategy. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Recent Insights

Behavioral Hacks for Your (Financial) New Year’s Resolutions

With the end of the year rapidly approaching, the time is once again upon us to set our New Year’s resolutions. Many of us will make our well-intentioned resolutions to get out of debt, increase our savings, or stick to a budget, only to find that we have fallen right back into our old habits by the time March rolls around. Sticking to New Year’s resolutions can be incredibly challenging, particularly when it comes to our finances. However, there are some tricks you can use to not only help you stick to your resolutions, but also set yourself and your family up for a successful financial future.

Talking Money this Holiday Season

With the fall and winter holiday season rapidly approaching, many are prepping to host their traditional family gatherings in new and creative ways in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the settings may be different this year, and we may be gathering virtually, one thing is unlikely to change: when family and friends gather, uncomfortable topics will come up in conversation. One of those topics is likely money and personal finances. In July of 2019, TD Ameritrade conducted a study that asked participants about their comfort levels discussing certain issues, primarily focusing on money/personal finances.
Financial chart and data with calculator and pen on wooden desk

8 Credit Building Tips for the Modern American

Here are some helpful tips to help you build and repair your financial reputation for a long-lasting impact.