Stock Market Predictions Are Worthless

Stock Market Predictions Are Worthless

I am not sure what our fascination with predictions is all about.  Whether it is political elections, sports, or the financial markets, everyone seems to be willing to stop and listen to someone willing to make a prediction.  Rarely do we ever go back to evaluate how those predictions pan out?  Regarding investment predictions, every once and awhile, I like to go back and check the accuracy of those prognosticators against the investment markets to see how they have held up.  One of the most famous is Jeremy Grantham, founder of GMO, a multi-billion dollar asset management company.  He periodically published a 7-year market prediction and gained quite a bit of notoriety for accurately predicting much of the investment returns in the early part of the 1990s.  As we approach the end of his 7-year forecast from June 30, 2008, I thought it would be helpful to evaluate his predictions (caveat- the index returns go through 5/31 while the GMO forecast is through 6/30):

Asset Class Index GMO Forecast Actual Return
US Large Cap Stocks S&P 500 3.2% 9.85%
US Small-Cap Stocks Russell 2000 2.1% 10.46%
Int’l Large-Cap Stocks MSCI EAFE 5.8% 2.42%
Int’l Small-Cap Stocks MSCI EAFE Small 6.2% 5.69%
US REITs DJ Select REIT 2.7% 8.4%
Emerging Mkt Stocks MSCI Emerging Mkts 6.8% 1.25%

 

So, if you had taken GMO’s advice and overweighted the areas they predicted would perform the best, you would have put most of your money in emerging market stocks and international stocks.  The asset classes that predicted the worst performance (US stocks and REITs) had been the best places to invest.  The point is, no one has a crystal ball.  Those that have been right in the past have no better chance of being right in the future.  Once you realize this, you’ll be a much better investor, immune from the siren song of predictions.

Information contained herein has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but its accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. It is not intended as the primary basis for financial planning or investment decisions and should not be construed as advice meeting the particular investment needs of any investor. This material has been prepared for information purposes only and is not a solicitation or an offer to buy any security or instrument or to participate in any trading strategy. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Recent Insights

Self-Employed Retirement Plans- Which Retirement Plan is Right for You?

Being self-employed, like many aspects of life, has both advantages and disadvantages. One major advantage is access to tax-advantaged retirement accounts with high contribution limits, flexible investment options, and relatively easy administration. Read about simple options that allow you to take the next step toward saving for your retirement.

What is a tax law sunset? More importantly, should I do anything?

Is the tax law sunset a thing of beauty, or does it signify the end of a good thing? In short, the sunset means tax rates are set to change in 2026.

Your Financial End-of-Year Checklist: Insurance Planning, Estate Planning, and Other Considerations

Having a financial plan going into the new year is incredibly important to help you meet your financial goals and to ensure that you are adequately prepared. In this second installment of your end-of-year financial checklist, we will be discussing insurance planning, estate planning, and other key considerations for you to plan for.